M1 Finance vs Public: Which Investing App Is Better?

Choosing the right investment platform depends on whether you prefer automated, long-term portfolio building or self-directed trading across multiple asset classes. In this detailed comparison of m1 finance vs public, we analyze how both financial technology platforms handle portfolio management, fee schedules, order execution, and account features to help you determine which tool aligns with your financial strategy.

While both platforms cater to modern retail investors looking for low-cost access to US markets, their core design philosophies differ fundamentally. M1 Finance functions primarily as a hybrid robo-advisor built around automated allocations, whereas Public operates as a versatile self-directed brokerage offering stocks, bonds, options, and alternative assets.

Platform Philosophies: Automated Pies vs. Flexible Self-Directed Investing

To understand how these platforms compare, it helps to examine their primary investment mechanisms.

M1 Finance: The Pie-and-Slice Architecture

M1 Finance relies on a proprietary framework called “Pies.” Instead of making individual stock trades throughout the day, you construct a target portfolio represented as a pie chart. Each stock or ETF represents a slice of that pie, assigned a specific target percentage (e.g., 50% Vanguard S&P 500 ETF, 30% Apple Inc., 20% Microsoft Corp.).

When you deposit funds into M1 Finance, the platform automatically allocates your cash across your slices to maintain your predetermined target percentages. This system, known as dynamic rebalancing, allows long-term investors to automatically buy underperforming assets at lower relative valuations without manually calculating order sizes.

Public: Modular, Multi-Asset Trading

Public (formerly Public.com) began as a fractional-share stock trading app with social feeds and has evolved into a comprehensive brokerage platform. Rather than forcing users into a single structured portfolio model, Public allows investors to buy individual shares, fractional equities, fixed-income assets, and crypto on demand.

Public also offers modular features such as automated dollar-cost averaging, high-yield cash accounts, and structured bond portfolios. However, execution remains immediate during active market hours, giving users precise control over order timing.

Order Execution Models: Trading Windows vs. Real-Time Orders

One of the most operational differences between M1 Finance and Public is how and when trades are executed on the exchange.

M1 Finance Execution Windows

M1 Finance does not offer real-time order execution. Instead, the platform aggregates user trades and executes them during designated daily trading windows:

  • Morning Trading Window: Starts around 9:30 AM Eastern Time on open market days.
  • Afternoon Trading Window: Available to users who meet specific platform requirements (such as maintaining account balances of $20,000 or higher).

Because trades execute only during these predefined windows, M1 Finance is poorly suited for day trading, swing trading, or placing time-sensitive limit orders. It is strictly engineered for buy-and-hold passive investing.

Public Execution Capabilities

Public provides standard brokerage execution during normal market hours (9:30 AM to 4:00 PM Eastern Time), along with extended-hours trading access for eligible accounts. Users can execute market orders, limit orders, and stop-loss orders in real time.

For investors who want to react to real-time earnings reports, economic data releases, or market volatility, Public offers the necessary order flexibility that M1 Finance intentionally omits.

M1 Finance vs Public: Fee Structures and Account Costs

Evaluating platform fees requires looking at baseline subscription costs, minimum balance thresholds, and secondary service fees.

M1 Finance Pricing Rules

Historically known as a completely free platform, M1 Finance introduced a streamlined platform fee structure to cover maintenance costs:

  • Monthly Platform Fee: $3 per month for clients with total platform assets under $20,000.
  • Fee Waiver: The $3 monthly fee is waived for clients who maintain an aggregate balance of $20,000 or more across M1 Investment, Earn, or Borrow accounts.
  • Commission: $0 management fees on custom portfolios.

This structure makes M1 Finance highly cost-effective for portfolio balances exceeding $20,000, while smaller accounts (e.g., $500 balances) face an annualized fee ratio that requires careful consideration.

Public Pricing Model

Public operates on a freemium pricing structure without mandatory account maintenance fees for standard accounts:

  • Standard Accounts: $0 commission on self-directed US stock and ETF trades.
  • Public Premium: An optional subscription costing $10 per month (or $96 annually), providing institutional-grade Morningstar research, advanced metrics, audio market calls, and access to an AI-driven analysis assistant named Alpha.
  • Fixed Income & Options: Options trades incur low per-contract regulatory and platform fees, while Treasury Bill accounts charge a management fee structured into the yield schedule.

For beginner investors starting with smaller initial deposits, Public’s fee-free baseline tier eliminates fixed monthly overhead.

Asset Class Availability and Account Types

Diversification options vary significantly between the two platforms.

Available Investment Assets

M1 Finance concentrates primarily on mainstream equity and debt instruments:

  • Exchange-traded stocks listed on major US exchanges (NYSE, NASDAQ).
  • Exchange-traded funds (ETFs).
  • Major cryptocurrencies through M1 Crypto accounts.

Public provides a broader spectrum of asset classes within a single user interface:

  • US stocks and ETFs (with fractional share support).
  • High-yield Treasury Bills (6-month T-Bills with automatic rollover options).
  • Corporate bonds and municipal bond portfolios.
  • Cryptocurrencies (handled via partner custodian services).
  • Index options trading.
  • Alternative assets, including fractional royalty rights and art (subject to secondary market availability).

Supported Account Classifications

Both platforms support standard individual taxable brokerage accounts, but M1 Finance offers a wider selection of tax-advantaged account structures.

  • M1 Finance Account Types: Individual Taxable, Joint Taxable, Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, SEP IRA, Custodial Accounts (UGMA/UTMA), and Trust Accounts.
  • Public Account Types: Individual Taxable Accounts, High-Yield Cash Accounts, and Treasury Accounts. Tax-advantaged retirement accounts (IRAs) may have limited rollout options compared to dedicated legacy brokerages.

If retirement planning via a Roth or Traditional IRA is your primary objective, M1 Finance provides a more robust account foundation.

Cash Management and Yield Products

Idle cash handling is an important consideration for investors looking to earn interest on uninvested capital.

M1 High-Yield Cash Account

M1 Finance provides a dedicated cash management account offering competitive Annual Percentage Yields (APY) on uninvested cash. Funds placed in the M1 High-Yield Cash Account are swept to partner banks, offering FDIC insurance coverage up to standard regulatory thresholds ($5 million through partner bank sweep networks).

Public High-Yield Cash Account

Public features a high-yield cash account that sweeps unbanked funds to partner financial institutions. Public’s cash account offers competitive variable APYs with no minimum deposit requirements and FDIC insurance coverage up to $5 million via sweep network banks. Additionally, Public offers direct access to US Treasury Bills, allowing users to lock in state-tax-exempt yields backed directly by the US government.

Platform Comparison Matrix

The following table outlines the feature availability and fee characteristics of M1 Finance and Public:

Feature / Parameter M1 Finance Public
Core Model Automated portfolio pies & rebalancing Self-directed trading & asset diversification
Base Monthly Fee $3/month (Waived if total balance ≥ $20,000) $0/month ($10/month for optional Premium)
Execution Method 1–2 designated daily trading windows Real-time market execution & extended hours
Retirement Accounts (IRAs) Yes (Traditional, Roth, SEP IRA) Limited / Primary focus on taxable accounts
Fixed Income Options Bond ETFs only Direct US Treasury Bills & Corporate Bonds
Options & Extended Trading No Yes
Automated Rebalancing Yes (Native dynamic rebalancing) No (Manual asset allocation)

Summary Recommendation: Matching Strategy to Platform

Neither platform is universally superior; the optimal choice depends entirely on your investment workflow and target account size.

  • Choose M1 Finance if: You are building a long-term passive portfolio or retirement account (Roth/Traditional IRA), have an initial or aggregate balance over $20,000, and want hands-free automated rebalancing using target pie allocations.
  • Choose Public if: You prefer self-directed real-time stock trading, want to invest directly in fixed-income assets like Treasury Bills and Corporate Bonds, or are managing smaller starting balances under $20,000 where monthly platform maintenance fees would diminish returns.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links in this article are affiliate links. If you open an account through these links, FinCrati may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. Our editorial assessments remain strictly objective and based on documented platform specifications.

To verify official terms, current APY rates, and disclosures, visit the official platform resources at M1 Finance Official Website, explore asset options on Public.com Official Site, or review general investor guidelines on the SEC Investor Information Portal.

Pros & Cons

M1 Finance

✅ Pros

  • Automated dynamic rebalancing based on custom target allocation percentages
  • Comprehensive IRA account options including Traditional, Roth, and SEP IRAs
  • Integrated margin lending (M1 Borrow) against eligible portfolio assets

❌ Cons

  • $3/month account maintenance fee for total balances under $20,000
  • Order execution limited to 1 or 2 designated daily trading windows

Public

✅ Pros

  • Real-time order execution with extended-hours trading support
  • Direct access to 6-month US Treasury Bills and corporate bond portfolios
  • $0 maintenance fee on standard self-directed accounts without minimum balance requirements

❌ Cons

  • Lacks native automated portfolio rebalancing features
  • Advanced research tools and AI assistant require a $10/month Premium subscription

Pricing Comparison

Public Premium

$10/month
  • All Standard tier features
  • Institutional Morningstar research reports
  • Alpha AI investment analysis assistant
  • Extended-hours trading access
Visit Official Site →

M1 Standard (< $20k Balance)

$3/month
  • Automated Pie-based portfolio allocation
  • Dynamic automated rebalancing
  • Access to taxable and IRA account types
  • High-Yield Cash Account access
Visit Official Site →

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you day trade on M1 Finance or Public?

You cannot day trade on M1 Finance because orders are aggregated and executed during 1 or 2 specific daily trading windows. Public supports real-time market execution during standard and extended trading hours, making it capable of executing intraday trades subject to standard FINRA pattern day trader rules.

Is M1 Finance free to use?

M1 Finance charges a $3 per month platform fee for users whose aggregate platform balances are under $20,000. For accounts maintaining $20,000 or more in total assets across M1 accounts, this fee is waived.

Does Public offer Roth IRAs?

Public focuses primarily on taxable brokerage accounts, high-yield cash accounts, and treasury accounts. Investors looking for dedicated Roth, Traditional, or SEP IRA retirement accounts will find broader support on platforms like M1 Finance.

How do cash interest rates on M1 Finance and Public work?

Both M1 Finance and Public partner with FDIC-insured banks to sweep uninvested cash into interest-bearing accounts. These cash accounts offer variable APYs competitive with high-yield savings accounts, providing up to $5 million in FDIC insurance through partner bank networks.

Which platform is better for beginner investors with under $1,000?

Public is generally more cost-effective for starting balances under $1,000 because it charges $0 in account maintenance fees. On M1 Finance, a $3 per month fee on a $500 account equates to a $36 annual cost, representing a 7.2% annual fee ratio.